Demo

Chief Financial Officer

Gregory & Appel Insurance
Indianapolis, IN Full Time
POSTED ON 1/26/2025
AVAILABLE BEFORE 4/26/2025

Job Description

Job Description

The Chief Financial Officer, CFO, will serve as a key strategic partner to the CEO, President and executive team, providing financial leadership and oversight for a growing independent insurance agency with $40M in recurring revenue and 165 employees. This role will be responsible for all aspects of financial strategy, planning, and operations while driving agency growth and operational excellence. The ideal candidate will bring strong financial leadership experience from professional services, recurring revenue businesses, or financial services industries, with the ability to quickly learn and adapt to the insurance agency business model.

Key Responsibilities

Strategic Leadership

  • Partner with CEO, President and executive team to develop and execute agency-wide strategic initiatives
  • Lead long-term financial planning and forecasting, with specific focus on recurring revenue streams
  • Drive business perpetuation strategy, including ownership transition planning and valuation
  • Lead M&A strategy, including target identification, due diligence, deal structuring, and post-merger integration
  • Provide data-driven insights on business performance and strategic opportunities
  • Develop and monitor key performance indicators for growth and operational efficiency
  • Structure and execute internal ownership transfer programs

Financial Management

  • Oversee all financial operations including accounting, financial planning and analysis, treasury, and tax
  • Develop and maintain robust financial controls and risk management systems
  • Lead annual budgeting process and monthly / quarterly forecasting
  • Manage banking relationships and ensure adequate capital structure
  • Drive operational efficiency and process improvement initiatives
  • Team Leadership

  • Build and mentor a high-performing finance team
  • Foster a culture of excellence, accountability, and continuous improvement
  • Serve as a trusted advisor to department heads on financial matters
  • Lead cross-functional initiatives requiring financial expertise
  • Years of Experience :

  • 7 years in senior financial leadership roles
  • 15 years of progressive finance experience
  • Education :

  • Bachelor's degree in Finance, Accounting, or related field.
  • MBA and / or CPA preferred
  • Technical Skills

    Required :

  • Deep expertise in financial planning, analysis, and modeling
  • Strong understanding of GAAP and financial reporting requirements
  • Proven experience managing recurring revenue business models
  • Proficiency with ERP systems and financial software
  • Experience with data analytics and business intelligence tools
  • Track record of managing complex commission / incentive structures
  • Demonstrated expertise in M&A due diligence and deal execution
  • Experience in business valuation and ownership transition planning
  • Background in structuring buy-sell agreements and succession plans
  • Excellence in building and analyzing financial models for business valuation
  • Experience with trust accounting and / or managing client funds
  • Preferred :

  • Knowledge of insurance agency metrics and KPIs
  • Familiarity with agency management systems
  • Understanding of carrier contingency bonus programs
  • Experience with premium finance operations
  • Background in professional services or financial services industry
  • Experience with generational business transitions
  • Knowledge of ESOP and other ownership transfer structures
  • Leadership & Soft Skills

  • Proven track record of leading and developing high-performing teams
  • Outstanding communication and presentation skills
  • Strategic mindset with strong business acumen
  • Change management and process improvement expertise
  • Ability to influence and collaborate across all levels of organization
  • Benefits :

  • Medical, Dental & Vision
  • Short-Term & Long-Term Disability
  • Extended Holiday Weekends
  • Paid Parental Leave
  • Company Matching Donations
  • 401k, Roth Option & Matching
  • Life Insurance
  • Hybrid Work Environment
  • Wellbeing Coaching
  • Mental Health Sessions
  • Tuition Reimbursement
  • Why Work at G&A?

    Gregory & Appel helps organizations and people grow through tailored risk management strategies. From helping companies with their business insurance programs and employee benefits offerings to helping individuals protect their assets – our team is the difference.

    Who wouldn’t want to work for a company that :

  • Supports community involvement
  • Prioritizes diversity, equity and belonging
  • Invests in your future
  • Gives 10% of profits back into the community
  • If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
    Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

    What is the career path for a Chief Financial Officer?

    Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Chief Financial Officer career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
    Income Estimation: 
    $266,435 - $399,322
    Income Estimation: 
    $324,621 - $462,386
    Income Estimation: 
    $324,621 - $462,386
    Income Estimation: 
    $439,981 - $947,023
    Income Estimation: 
    $131,172 - $174,437
    Income Estimation: 
    $173,200 - $238,103
    View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

    Job openings at Gregory & Appel Insurance

    Gregory & Appel Insurance
    Hired Organization Address Indianapolis, IN Full Time
    Job Description The Systems Administrator is a highly dependable and motivated professional. This position is responsibl...
    Gregory & Appel Insurance
    Hired Organization Address Indianapolis, IN Full Time
    Job Description The Employee Benefits Director of Revenue Operations will oversee and manage the Employee Benefits insur...

    Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Chief Financial Officer jobs in the Indianapolis, IN area that may be a better fit.

    Chief Wealth Planning Officer

    Oxford Financial Group, Ltd., Indianapolis, IN

    Chief Financial Officer - ACS

    City of Indianapolis and Marion County, Animal Care Services, IN

    AI Assistant is available now!

    Feel free to start your new journey!