Demo

Chief Operating Officer

The Carlisle Group (TCG)
Indianapolis, IN Full Time
POSTED ON 4/8/2025
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/7/2025

Our client, a growing regional carrier rated A Excellent by A.M. Best, is seeking to hire a talented Chief Operating Officer (COO). The role, reporting to the CEO, will have significant impact across the entire P&L. The client is seeking an executive with a demonstrated track record of success in P&L ownership, bringing new products to market, and driving innovation throughout the business.


General Summary:

The COO is accountable for driving operational excellence, growing the company, improving profitability, and ensuring the company’s day-to-day operations run efficiently and effectively while maintaining compliance with laws and regulations to serve our policyholders and meet their evolving needs. To achieve this, the COO works closely with the other Executive Team policyholders and provides strategic leadership and operational oversight of Underwriting, Product Development, Claims, Sales, and agency and policyholder services.

Duties and Responsibilities:

Overall Leadership

  • Guide the organization by consistently modeling our ICARE cultural values and continuously enhancing the soft skills of our leaders
  • Lead and/or support company initiatives that drive cross-functional team collaboration and connection.
  • Oversee strategic operations within the departments of responsibility with full accountability for team performance, including responsibility for financial results
  • Evaluate and optimize workflow and process improvements to enhance agent and policyholder service capacity, quality, and cost efficiency
  • Partner with HR to identify, recruit, hire, and onboard top-tier managers and associates where needs are identified in the organization to achieve the Company’s corporate goals and strategic objectives
  • Partner with HR to identify opportunities to grow company’s internal talent to provide long-term career opportunities and plans to achieve upward mobility for high performers
  • Mentor, coach, and guide operational leaders or potential leaders in the organization to develop strong succession throughout the organization
  • Set and assign operational goals for all departments of responsibility consistent with the overall company budgets and long-term goals
  • Collaborate with CFO and GC to evolve the audit and controls processes to align with model audit rule (MAR) and own risk solvency risk assessment (ORSA) requirements
  • Ensure that all activities and operations are performed in compliance with local, state, and federal laws & insurance department statutes


Setting Strategic Direction

  • Collaborate with the CEO and other Executive Team policyholders on strategic planning and the company’s long-term vision Drive prioritization of strategic initiatives and collaborate with the CFO, CIO and others to ensure execution
  • Collaborate with the CEO to establish goals and guidelines for operational functions within the organization
  • Collaborate with the CEO, CFO, and GC on mergers and acquisition evaluation, and potentially, analysis to integration


Managing Products

  • Ensure products are managed to be market competitive and differentiated where appropriate
  • Evaluate and optimize the product management process to manage products cost effectively and be more responsive to the market
  • Collaborate with the CIO to streamline product implementation through IT using an Agile process
  • Collaborate with the CFO and head of pricing to ensure rates and pricing align with the product initiatives


Managing Sales

  • Work with Independent agencies to develop strong relationships, profitable growth opportunities, and ensure our distribution relationships remain our biggest competitive advantage
  • Expand our distribution base to continue to grow the company while managing the impact on current relationships
  • Ensure agency needs and issues are addressed through process, automation, product enhancements, people management, etc.
  • Oversee and work through distribution issues including problem agents, and errors and omissions.


Managing Underwriting

  • Oversee underwriting guidelines and ensure effective and efficient adherence to those guidelines
  • Expand automated underwriting to improve agency experience while minimizing risk and exposure
  • Identify and lead implementation of improved underwriting processes and process automation
  • Improve use of data / analytics in the management of underwriting practices


Managing Claims

  • Ensure our Claims operation delivers our envisioned policyholder experienced while balancing the long-term viability of the company Identify and lead implementation of improved claim processes and process automation
  • Improve use of data / analytics in the management of claim practices


Managing Agency and Policyholder Services

  • Lead the buildout and ongoing management of the agency service center
  • Ensure the delivery of market-leading agency and policyholder services through processes, interactions, and call centers


Skills and Abilities:

  • Leadership Skills: Leads effectively and influence others through communication, decision making, emotional intelligence, vision and strategy, delegation, team building and collaboration, adaptability and flexibility, integrity and ethics, coaching and development, and is results-oriented to inspire, guide, and manage teams to be high performing and cohesive
  • Strategic Thinking: Identify strategies and tactics to leverage the company’s core competencies to enhance the value proposition to agents and policyholders while identifying areas for service delivery improvements, and process improvements to enhance the policyholder experience and drive more efficient and cost-effective operations.
  • Innovation/Initiative/Creativity: Approaches problems with curiosity and an open mind; is willing to take appropriate risk and collaborate to solve problems.
  • Collaboration/Teamwork: Demonstrates emotional intelligence and works with others to solve problems, respects other views and ideas, and appropriately giving and receiving feedback.
  • Communication: Presents ideas and facts clearly and effectively, tailoring communication to the level and experience of the audience; keeps people accurately informed and up to date with both positive and potentially negative information.
  • Executive presence: Able to inspire confidence in associates, peers and Board policyholders on strategic plans and achievements.
  • Customer Orientation: Demonstrates customer focus by seeking out, understanding, and responding to the needs of both internal and external customers/agents/policyholders.
  • Drive for Results: Handles multiple projects/initiatives at the same time, delivers by deadline dates, and adjusts work and resources accordingly to meet changing priorities.
  • Analytical skills: Ability translate data insights into actionable strategies, guide team decisions and improve results.
  • Technical Competence: Strong understanding of the insurance business functions across the value chain and supporting technology to guide strategy and manage operations.
  • Distribution Management: Knowledge of Independent Agent distribution system and functions and ability to develop and manage agent relationships.
  • Reinsurance: Knowledge of reinsurance structures and negotiations.


Ethics and Integrity

  • Make decisions based on what's right for the greater good and sets an example for others to follow. Must be honest, fair, and caring, and consider the needs of their associates, agents, policyholders, and communities.


Minimum Qualifications:

  • Bachelor’s degree is required and a Master’s degree (MBA) or equivalent is preferred
  • 15 years of progressive leadership experience in a P&C organization
  • CIC/CPCU designation a plus
  • Proven experience managing profitability within a property and casualty insurance operation.
  • Demonstrated ability to lead and mentor other managers and leaders to drive team performance.
  • Expertise in process improvement and leveraging technology to automate workflows and enhance operational efficiency.
  • In-depth knowledge of insurance products and operations, with a specialized focus on workers' compensation.
  • Strong interpersonal skills, with a track record of collaborating effectively across diverse leadership teams.

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Chief Operating Officer?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Chief Operating Officer career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$81,491 - $99,340
Income Estimation: 
$70,269 - $88,771
Income Estimation: 
$118,463 - $170,220
Income Estimation: 
$58,150 - $75,291
Income Estimation: 
$70,269 - $88,771
Income Estimation: 
$81,491 - $99,340
Income Estimation: 
$118,463 - $170,220
Income Estimation: 
$100,023 - $130,370
Income Estimation: 
$145,026 - $211,208
Income Estimation: 
$118,463 - $170,220
Income Estimation: 
$70,269 - $88,771
Income Estimation: 
$100,023 - $130,370
Income Estimation: 
$118,463 - $170,220
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at The Carlisle Group (TCG)

The Carlisle Group (TCG)
Hired Organization Address Cumberland, MD Full Time
Pay: $65-70/hour The Carlisle Group is currently recruiting for a Pharmacist for a great retailer in the Cumberland, Mar...
The Carlisle Group (TCG)
Hired Organization Address Charlotte, NC Full Time
Chief Revenue Officer (CRO) We have been retained to fill an important role within our client. They are an industry lead...
The Carlisle Group (TCG)
Hired Organization Address Morgantown, PA Full Time
Job Description With over 100 years in metal saw manufacturing, our client has clearly positioned itself as the technolo...
The Carlisle Group (TCG)
Hired Organization Address Joplin, MO Full Time
Commercial Lines Producer Commercial Lines Producer, is a key sales role. This organization has been selected as the num...

Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Chief Operating Officer jobs in the Indianapolis, IN area that may be a better fit.

Chief Operating Officer

VisionSpark, Indianapolis, IN

Chief Operating Officer

QLM Search, Indianapolis, IN

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!