Demo

Director of Commissions

Exact Medicare
Westerville, OH Full Time
POSTED ON 3/7/2025
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/6/2025

About Exact Medicare


Company Overview

Exact Medicare was founded with a clear vision: to simplify the complex world of Medicare for retirees and provide them with the confidence they need to make informed healthcare decisions. What started as a humble operation with a deep understanding of the challenges retirees face—endless mail, confusing options, and relentless calls—has since grown into something truly special. Today, we’re proud to be recognized as the fastest growing Medicare brokerage firm in America. We’ve expanded nationwide, bringing together some of the most trusted agencies in the country. Hundreds of independent licensed sales agents have joined our ranks, and we’ve attracted world-class talent to our corporate team. As we’ve come together and joined forces on this amazing journey, we’re all empowered by our core values, which drive everything we do.


Our Core Values

  • Extreme Ownership: We take ownership of our actions and responsibilities, delivering the best possible results for our clients.
  • Above Reproach: We uphold the highest standards of integrity and ethics in all interactions and decisions.
  • Culture of Candor: We foster a culture of open and honest communication, valuing ideas and feedback to continuously improve.
  • Atomic Growth: We are committed to continuous personal and organizational growth to better serve our clients and community.


Position Overview

We are seeking a highly experienced and strategic Director of Commissions to lead and oversee the entire commissions strategy and operations. This individual will be responsible for directing overall commissions operations, ensuring the accurate and efficient processing of commission statements, and optimizing all aspects of commission workflows. They will take a hands-on approach in structuring the department, actively managing personnel, and ensuring best practices are established and followed to improve efficiency and compliance while maintaining detailed oversight of all commission-related operations.

As the key decision-maker for commissions strategy, this role requires a highly analytical and detail-oriented approach to develop policies, implement scalable solutions, and drive operational improvements that enhance financial performance. The ideal candidate must possess an exceptional ability to scrutinize complex commission structures, identify discrepancies, and ensure precision in all aspects of commission management. The Director of Commissions will work closely with internal stakeholders—including Technology, Data Analytics, Finance, and Sales—to align commission strategies with broader business objectives. This individual will collaborate with our development team to identify and remediate issues in our Back Office commissions software and implement new features to enhance the agent experience. Additionally, this role will serve as the primary liaison with carriers to manage compensation structures, resolve discrepancies, and strengthen commission tracking processes.


Job Duties


  • Oversee the full lifecycle of commission processing, ensuring timely and accurate integration into our Back Office software.

  • Lead the commission processing team responsible for managing incoming carrier statements.

  • Design and implement compensation grids for new products as well as new changes to pay structure of our agents.

  • Direct the commissions support team in handling agent inquiries related to payouts, discrepancies, and system issues.

  • Establish and implement auditing procedures to ensure payout accuracy before submission to payroll.

  • Identify, investigate, and resolve commission discrepancies through in-depth data analysis and collaboration with internal teams.

Collaboration & Leadership

  • Work closely with the Director of Data Analytics to facilitate smooth data ingestion from carrier commission statements and application submissions.

  • Partner with the Finance Team to reconcile commissions receivable, ensuring accurate accounting and financial forecasting.

  • Collaborate with the Technology Team to enhance and maintain our Back Office software, addressing system bugs and driving feature improvements.

  • Partner with the Technology Team in the development of a Policy Inventory System to track all sold policies and identify any missing commission payments.

  • Serve as the primary liaison with carriers, fostering strong relationships, negotiating compensation grids, and resolving commission-related issues.

  • Provide critical reporting and insights to C-suite executives, board members, and sales leadership to support data-driven business decisions.

Strategic Leadership & Process Optimization

  • Lead, mentor, and manage the commissions team, fostering a culture of accountability and operational excellence.

  • Implement industry best practices to optimize the commission processing workflow and reduce errors.

  • Adapt to industry changes, ensuring company processes remain compliant and efficient in response to evolving carrier structures and compensation models.

  • Develop and maintain clear documentation and training programs for the commissions processing and support teams.


Minimum Qualifications


  • Proven experience in commissions processing or finance
  • Experience in the insurance and healthcare industry preferred
  • Bachelor's Degree required, Master's preferred
  • Proven experience leading teams


The pay range for this role is:

90,000 - 100,000 USD per year(Westerville, OH)

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Director of Commissions?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Director of Commissions career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$84,660 - $113,309
Income Estimation: 
$109,829 - $147,099
Income Estimation: 
$198,976 - $271,567
Income Estimation: 
$250,557 - $384,186
Income Estimation: 
$175,165 - $219,883
Income Estimation: 
$271,516 - $422,299
Income Estimation: 
$261,260 - $370,192
Income Estimation: 
$174,196 - $220,425
Income Estimation: 
$235,645 - $292,423
Income Estimation: 
$175,165 - $219,883
Income Estimation: 
$200,471 - $254,173
Income Estimation: 
$137,274 - $178,415
Income Estimation: 
$182,502 - $249,036
Income Estimation: 
$207,946 - $249,343
Income Estimation: 
$175,165 - $219,883
Income Estimation: 
$182,642 - $260,237
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Exact Medicare

Exact Medicare
Hired Organization Address Westerville, OH Full Time
About Exact Medicare Company Overview Exact Medicare was founded with a clear vision: to simplify the complex world of M...

Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Director of Commissions jobs in the Westerville, OH area that may be a better fit.

Insurance Agent (Base salary + Uncapped commissions)

Comparion Insurance Agency, Westerville, OH

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!